0
Belly Posted 18 years ago
Grammar

Some questions on the SAT

01) I encountered this sentence in Harry Potter:02br
02br
00"There was a great road from the motorbike and Harry felt the sidecar 01b00give 02b00a nasty lurch"02br
02br
00Why give can go with felt here?02br
02br
002) In my SAT preparation, I encounter this problem:02br
02br
00"The whopping crane population has increased from only 15 to about 2 hundred, 01u00which is one of conservation's most encouraging stories02u02br
02br
00A) which is one of conservation's most encouraging stories02br
02br
00b) which is one of the most encouraging stories in conservation02br
02br
00c) and this one of conservation's most encouraging stories02br
02br
00d) and this growth is one of conservation's most encouraging stories02br
02br
00E) and that appears to be encouraging to conservationists02br
02br
00The answer is D. But I don't still get it, 01b00which02b00 stand after a comma can subtitute for the clause which comes before it, why can't it be the correct answer here? And the answer book also says that: The act of changing which to this does not solve the problem of a pronoun's lack of specific antecedent. I don't get the whole thing02br
02br
003) 01u00I came in 15 minutes late which02u00 made the whole class difficult to understand02br
02br
00A) I came in 15 mintues late, and this 02br
02br
00B) coming in fifteen minutes late02br
02br
00B is the correct answer. But why not a? They say: The pronounce "which" has no specific antecedent here, and the change of which to this does not correct the problem.... Why??? 0-
  

Top answer

01) Perfectly good English:02br 05002br 002) What they mean is that "which" should replace a clear word in the preceding part of the sentence, and that doesn't exist here, thus they first create in D that word "the growth" which shows up clearly as a subject for the 2nd part of the sentence. 02br 003) The original cannot be separated in two distinct independent sentences, while A can be, esp with the comma. q=%22felt+*+heart+give%22&btnG=Search+Books

— Marius Hancu

  • 01) Perfectly good English:02br 05002br 002) What they mean is that "which" should replace a clear word in the preceding part of the sentence, and that doesn't exist here, thus they first create in D that word "the growth" which shows up clearly as a subject for the 2nd part of the sentence.
  • 02br 003) The original cannot be separated in two distinct independent sentences, while A can be, esp with the comma.
  • q=%22felt+*+heart+give%22&btnG=Search+Books
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

7 Answers
0
01) Perfectly good English:02br
05002br
002) What they mean is that "which" should replace a clear word in the preceding part of the sentence, and that doesn't exist here, thus they first create in D that word "the growth" which shows up clearly as a subject for the 2nd part of the sentence. 02br
003) The original cannot be separated in two distinct indepen
0
0
0I'm sorry, but it has to be "gave", doesn't it?0-
0
0
0No, it must be 01i00"give."02i02br
02br
00It's 01i00"felt the car (to) give"02i00 but "to" has been lost in time ... Thus it's an atemporal, infinitive form. 02br
00Similar/equivalent to: 02br
02br
01i00"felt the car giving a jolt" 02i0-
0
0
0 01blockquote
01cite10Belly12cite10"There was a great road from the motorbike and Harry felt the sidecar 11b10give 12b10a nasty lurch"12br
12br
10Why give can go with felt here?12br
12blockquote
10See 05002br
02br
00CJ 040pid513446
0
0
0Hi,02br
02br
00refer back to the question again, I've seen which represent the whole clause which comes before it:02br
02br
00He got married again a year later, 01b00which 02b00surprised everybody0-
0
0
0I posted your question 2 to another forum. Here's an answer from the moderator:02br
02br
00Perhaps it helps. 0230hrefhttp://thegrammarexchange.infopop.cc/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/340600179/m/4441002074
0
0
0Hi Jery, thanks so much for helping me, according to 01a05000 02a00 , he believes 01b00stories 02b00is the problem, not about which or that, so I believe the answer of the book is somewhat off the mark0230hrefhttp://thegrammarexchange.infopop.cc/eve/forum
0

Related Questions