0
Lcchang Posted 13 years ago
Grammar

so why? but why?

Your actions toward him have been terrible; you've demoralized him, made him cry and broken his spirit, so why are you so surprised he left without a word.

Can we say "but" instead of "so"? I feel like the meaning of the first sentence contradicts the second, so but should be perfect to be used here.
  

Top answer

Can we say "but" instead of "so"? I feel like the meaning of the first sentence contradicts the second, so but should be perfect to be used here. I agree with you.

  • Can we say "but" instead of "so"?
  • I feel like the meaning of the first sentence contradicts the second, so but should be perfect to be used here.
  • I agree with you.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
LcchangYour actions toward him have been terrible; you've demoralized him, made him cry and broken his spirit, so why are you so surprised he left without a word.Can we say "but" instead of "so"? I feel like the meaning of the first sentence contradicts the second, so but should be perfect to be used here.
I agree with you.
0
LcchangYour actions toward him have been terrible; you've demoralized him, made him cry and broken his spirit; so why are you so surprised he left without a word?
so has the value of 'this being so', 'given that this is true', 'if all this is true, then ...'.

CJ

Related Questions