0
Anonymous Posted 7 years ago
Grammar

So much confusion!!!

Suppose, I sold my phone on 10th January.

I sold my phone because if I didn't, he would take it away.

This sentence is correct and it means if I didn’t sell it when I had the opportunity to sell it, he was going to take it away at a later time on the 10th January or later. It is basically the past of “if I don’t sell my phone, he will take it away.”.

and,

I sold my phone because if I hadn’t, he would’ve taken it away.

This sentence is correct and it means I sold it on 10th March. If I didn’t, he was going to take it the same day, 10th January.

Do you agree? Or can someone explain better please?

  

Top answer

Duplicate question. Please do not post the same question twice. Thanks.

  • Duplicate question.
  • Please do not post the same question twice.
  • Thanks.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0

Duplicate question. Please do not post the same question twice. Thanks.

0
anonymous if I didn't

The past tense after IF generally refers to future time. It makes a supposition about an act that may occur in the future. It's like asking What if this happens? What will the result be?

I don't think you understand that because it sounds contradictory. But that's how it really is.

If I bought a puppy, ... ~ Su

Related Questions