" But the first one doesn't make much sense. Your readers (or listeners) will understand that what's fallen isn't the same cracker you picked up -- what once was whole is now in two pieces -- so they will expect you to pick up what's there, not what used to be. Pluralize.
New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.
But the first one doesn't make much sense. Your readers (or listeners) will understand that what's fallen isn't the same cracker you picked up -- what once was whole is now in two pieces -- so the
"The cracker fell and broke in two pieces, so I picked it up."
"The cracker fell and broke in two pieces, so I picked them up."