0
Reegis Posted 9 years ago
Grammar

She was typing on a computer keyboard.

Hello.

Is the sentence below correct? Does it sound complete for a native speaker?

She was typing on a computer keyboard.
  

Top answer

That is grammatically fine, but I suspect that it contains redundancy in the context. That is the only kind of keyboard we use nowadays.

  • That is grammatically fine, but I suspect that it contains redundancy in the context.
  • That is the only kind of keyboard we use nowadays.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

11 Answers
0
That is grammatically fine, but I suspect that it contains redundancy in the context. That is the only kind of keyboard we use nowadays.
0
In what context can I use it as a standalone sentence?

I remember that I was warned by many non-native English teachers to use the past continuous rather rarely - mainly in situations that refer to:
a) an interrupted action in the past
She was typing on a computer keyboard when her telephone rang.
b) a specific time as an interruption
Yesterday at this time, s
0
ReegisIn what context can I use it as a standalone sentence?
Your question gives you the answer. The sentence needs context, such as someone asking "What was she doing when you saw her". The sentence cannot stand alone.
0
So my information is correctEmotion: smile Thanks for your confirmation, fivejedjon.
0
I have just come across one more sentence with the past continuous that seems non-standard to me without context:

The children who were playing near the pipe are all sick now.

fivejedjon, could you please say whether it is correct and in what context you would use it?
0
ReegisThe children who were playing near the pipe are all sick now.
It is fine. They were playing in the past and they are sick at present.
0
Hmmm, so is there any difference between

The children who were playing near the pipe are all sick now.
and

The children who played near the pipe are all sick now.
?
0
Reegisso is there any difference betweenThe children who were playing near the pipe are all sick now.andThe children who played near the pipe are all sick now.
In meaning? No.
0
This is interesting... So can I use both sentences interchangeably?
0
Different ways of referring to a situation are rarely completely interchangeable at all times. However, for this situation, either would normally be possible. More context might make one more likely than the other.

Related Questions