0
Magda Posted 20 years ago
Grammar

She is always helping other the poor ...

Hi, could you tell me what this sentence implies: "She is always helping other the poor."
Thank you
  

Top answer

Are you sure that's exactly what it says Magda? It makes no sense as it stands.

  • Are you sure that's exactly what it says Magda?
  • It makes no sense as it stands.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

9 Answers
0
Are you sure that's exactly what it says Magda?

It makes no sense as it stands.
0
Oh, of course it makes no sense. Sorry!
"She is always helping the poor."
0
Ah!

Using the 'present continuous + always' usually indicates an annoying habit.

In your example the speaker probably does not like her 'helping the poor'. The problem here is that perhaps we might not see 'helping the poor' as something negative or annoying, if we are altruistic.

However, consider the following examples of more explicit annoying habits:

He's a
0
I don't agree that always + present continuous is limited to annoying actions. It certainly CAN be used that way, but my instinct is not that the speaker wants to convey annoyance - tone of voice would tell me that. In writing, I find it neutral.

Nona is such a kind person. She's always out there, helping the less fortunate.

I thought her sentence. was okay.
0
She is always helping the poor.

Fine in AmE. In AmE always in that structure can indicate annoyance, but it doesn't have to.

Oops! GG, I didn't know you were also answering while I was. We agree, anyway!

CJ
0
Thank you all! Can it also express gratitude?
0
GG and CJ,

As Magda's question asks what this sentence would imply... What would you suggest?

Using GG's inclusion of the aspect of intonation, which is very important if this sentence were to be spoken, it could imply many things... including 'gratitude'... depending on how it was said...
0
Given that no particular intonation was specified, I would suggest that the sentence implies frequent and continual involvement in projects aimed at helping the poor.

CJ
0
Well, it COULD be gratitude - or admiration - or wonder. Or even, as Tam said, annoyance. Context is important.

She has no time for her own family because she is always helping the poor.

I don't know what this town would do without her. She is always helping the poor.

She is so selfless - always helping the poor.

Related Questions