...she has a birthday???

[nq:1]Is it correct to say, "she has a birthday"? Lately, I've come across sucha sentence in a student's composition. I thought he should have written"it's her birthday" but my colleagues say it's ok? What's your opinion? Please share your views.[/nq]
Both forms are common and correct. Other valid
forms include "It is her birthday," "Her birthday is today" and so on. No rule of English pre

[nq:1]Hi, Is it correct to say, "she has a birthday"? Lately, I've come across sucha sentence in a student's composition. I thought he should have written"it's her birthday" but my colleagues say it's ok? What's your opinion? Please share your views. Regards: GForc[/nq]
It is not a complete sentence.

[nq:1]Hi, Is it correct to say, "she has a birthday"?[/nq]
It is "correct", but what does it mean? We all have birthdays. What other option is there?
[nq:1]I thought he should have written "it's her birthday",[/nq]
That is the correct sentence if the day really is her birthday.
[nq:1]but my colleagues say it's ok?[/nq]
So much for colleagues. Never trust them.
[nq:1]What's

Thanks for help
U¿ytkownik "Grzegorz Forc" (Email Removed) napisa³ w wiadomo¶ci

Both correct? No, In the case of "she has a birthday": everyone has a birthday, and it doesn't mean today is her birthday. Now "It's her birthday", and "Her birthday's today" would be correct.

[nq:1]Both correct? No, In the case of "she has a birthday": everyone has a birthday, and it doesn't mean today is her birthday. Now "It's her birthday", and "Her birthday's today" would be correct.[/nq]
The question emerged from a written text, not oral speech: so the question can deal only with grammar or syntax and not with factual truth (whether today is her birthday or not.)

Don