0
Taka Posted 14 years ago
Grammar

Separate

The garden fence, a conspicuously displayed boundary line, often no more than a token barrier, is the outer territorial limits, separating the private world of the family from the public world beyond.

About the 'separating' above, is it reduced adverbial clause, or a modifier of 'the outer territorial limits'?
  

Top answer

It's an alternative expression for "which separate". So (looking it up) it's a reduced adverbial clause. I would have made "limits" singular, as it says there is only one fence.

  • It's an alternative expression for "which separate".
  • So (looking it up) it's a reduced adverbial clause.
  • I would have made "limits" singular, as it says there is only one fence.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

6 Answers
0
It's an alternative expression for "which separate". So (looking it up) it's a reduced adverbial clause. I would have made "limits" singular, as it says there is only one fence.
0
So does this also work?

Separating the private world of the family from the public world beyond, the garden fence, a conspicuously displayed boundary line, often no more than a token barrier, is the outer territorial limits.
0
It doesn't look like a clause to me, not even a reduced one. It's a participle phrase. If I had to label it more specifically, I would say adverbial.
0
Aspara GusIt doesn't look like a clause to me, not even a reduced one. It's a participle phrase. If I had to label it more specifically, I would say adverbial.
So you don't think it's a modifier of 'limits', AG?
0
"Separating the private world of the family from the public world beyond, the garden fence, a conspicuously displayed boundary line, often no more than a token barrier, is the outer territorial limits."
It's far too long for a sentence with so many concepts joined together.This is what I think of as speed bump writing. It holds up your reading, because you have to untangle it in
0
TakaSo you don't think it's a modifier of 'limits', AG?
I'm not sure. Which word or phrase it modifies depends on its position in the sentence, I would think.

Separating the private world of the family from the public world beyond, the garden fence, a conspicuously displayed boundary line, often no more than a token barrier, is the outer

Related Questions