0
Anonymous Posted 12 years ago
Grammar

Sentence inquiry

Which one is right?
I did what you had suggested and it worked out well.
I did what you had suggested and it worked out well.

Should it be with 'had' or without?
  

Top answer

Which one is right? I did what you had suggested and it worked out well. I did what you suggested and it worked out well.

  • Which one is right?
  • I did what you had suggested and it worked out well.
  • I did what you suggested and it worked out well.
  • Should it be with 'had' or without?
  • Both are OK.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

8 Answers
0
Which one is right?
I did what you had suggested and it worked out well.
I did what you suggested and it worked out well.

Should it be with 'had' or without? Both are OK. The meaning is clear.
0
Thank you. So the use of 'had' has no major effect here?

Please tell me in what instances should had be used when talking about the past.
0
Very broadly speaking, we often avoid using Past Perfect in cases where the meaning is clear without it.
eg Mary cooked dinner before Tom came home.

But now consider these two examples.
(1) Tom came home at 6pm. Mary cooked dinner.
0
That was clear. Thanks. So basically the of use of 'had' refers to a an event prior to an event in the past. I am not sure if what I said is clear.

And as you said, it depends on clarity and context, because you gave examples which mean the same, the first and the last one.

Lastly, what if I said in the second example: Mary cooked dinner before then. Would that be clear without '
0
Yes, You have the right general understanding of all this.

Clive
0
That is great, thank you.

What about my question on your second example: ........... Mary cooked dinner before then.

Is it now clear after adding (before then) without 'had', or should 'had' still be included?
0
Words like before/after/then make the sequence clear, so Simple Past is commonly used.
eg He watched TV after he ate dinner.

Clive
0
Thanks. I would like to know if it is ok not to use had in this sentence, after adding before then.

Tom came home at 6pm. Mary cooked dinner before then.

Also, would it be correct to say:
He ate dinner and then watched TV.
He ate dinner before (watching TV) or (he watched TV). Would watching indicate that he is presently watching TV, and he watched indicates that it was i

Related Questions