0
Usenet Posted 22 years ago
Learning

Sentence improvement

From=20exercises (7a-7i) in "The Random House Handbook," 5th Ed. by Frederick Crews:

Each of the following sentences needs improvement on grounds of insufficiently distinct expression.. rewrite the sentence to align main features of meaning with main grammatical units.. use fewer words to convey the idea...

C. The tar sand oil is so heavy that it cannot be pumped and instead must be strip-mined with the sand and then subjected to a process of treatment whereby the oil and sand are separated by hot water, steam, and air.

E. A choice must be made between goals of oil production to be maintained if the world is not to run out of vital energy supplies and the understandable reluctance felt by many people to permit the devastating if perhaps temporary damage caused by strip mining. --

My attempt at revision:

The tar sand oil, unpumpable due to its heaviness, must instead be strip-mined with the sand and then treated by hot water, steam, and air to separate the oil from the sand.

(Have I altered the original meaning too much? Any better suggestions at rewriting it?)

A choice must be made between maintaining oil production to prevent the exhaustion of vital energy supplies and permitting the devastating albeit temporary damage caused by strip mining.

(But still, what remains to be the "main grammatical units" is "choice must be made," giving scanty information, besides being a passive voice. Also I have ruthlessly stripped away "many people"s feelings. So I think my revision is still not good. Any suggestions?)

Many thanks in advance.

-- P.S.

I'm posting this message on alt.usage.german too, because several habitu=1B.A=8E=E9=*** there have excellent English skills, who, I think, c= an help my English problems as well as my German ones as they did.
  

Top answer

From exercises (7a-7i) in "The Random House Handbook," 5th Ed. by Frederick Crews: Each of the following sentences needs improvement on grounds of insufficiently distinct expression.. rewrite the sentence to align main features of meaning with main grammatical units..

  • From exercises (7a-7i) in "The Random House Handbook," 5th Ed.
  • by Frederick Crews: Each of the following sentences needs improvement on grounds of insufficiently distinct expression..
  • rewrite the sentence to align main features of meaning with main grammatical units..
  • use fewer words to convey the idea...
  • C.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

11 Answers
0
From exercises (7a-7i) in "The Random House Handbook," 5th Ed. by Frederick Crews:

Each of the following sentences needs improvement on grounds of insufficiently distinct expression.. rewrite the sentence to align main features of meaning with main grammatical units.. use fewer words to convey the idea...

C. The tar sand oil is so heavy that it cannot be pumped and instead must
0
[nq:1] From exercises (7a-7i) in "The Random House Handbook," 5th Ed. by Frederick Crews: Each of the following sentences needs ... mining. Adrian: We have a choice: ensure energy supply through strip-mining, or appease those who dislike the damage it causes.[/nq]
I really like your revisions, concise and powerful. Vielen Dank!
0
[nq:2] From exercises (7a-7i) in "The Random House Handbook," 5th ... is then separated from the sand with hot water,steam and[/nq]
[nq:1]air.[/nq]
[nq:2]E. A choice must be made between goals of oil ... throughstrip-mining, or appease those who dislike the damage it causes.[/nq]
[nq:1]I really like your revisions, concise and powerful. Vielen Dank! Another choice is nukes. Much cheap
0
[nq:1]Adrian: We have a choice: ensure energy supply through strip-mining, or appease those who dislike the damage it causes. Another ... launched a jihad. If we sink into serious global warning the people most at fault will be the so-called Greenies.[/nq]
I agree with you 100%. (Ich stimme dir völlig zu.)
[nq:1]I tried to explain to one how nuclear power production actually red
0
[nq:2] From exercises (7a-7i) in "The Random House Handbook," 5th ... then separated from the sand with hot water, steam and[/nq]
[nq:1]air.[/nq]
[nq:2]E. A choice must be made between goals of oil ... strip-mining, or appease those who dislike the damage it causes.[/nq]
[nq:1]I really like your revisions, concise and powerful. Vielen Dank![/nq]
Bitte sehr. My versions aren't perf
0
[nq:2]Adrian: We have a choice: ensure energy supply through strip-mining, ... warning the people most at faultwill be the so-called Greenies.[/nq]
[nq:1]I agree with you 100%. (Ich stimme dir völlig zu.)[/nq]
[nq:2]I tried to explain to one how nuclear power production actually reduces the radioactivity of the earth.[/nq]
[nq:1]You are right. (Du hast recht.)[/nq]
[nq:2]Hi
0
[nq:2]C. The tar sand oil is so heavy that it ... and sand are separated by hot water, steam, and air.[/nq]
[nq:1]Adrian: The tar sand oil, too heavy to be pumped, is strip-mined with the sand; the oil is then separated ... versions aren't perfect: the first one has two clashinguses of "with", and the second sacrifices at least three ideas. (...)[/nq]
Then how about: "The tar sand oil, to
0
[nq:2]But he's also right, as he's not concerned with the total radioactivity of the earth, rather, the potential amount of radioactivity released to the biosphere.[/nq]
[nq:1]Wrong on that count as well! Coal-fired power plants release far more radiation, in the form of radon, than nukes.[/nq]
Right, I forgot to take that into account.

A related question (since you seem t
0
[nq:2]Wrong on that count as well! Coal-fired power plants release far more radiation, in the form of radon, than nukes.[/nq]
[nq:1]Right, I forgot to take that into account. A related question (since you seem to know a lot about thissubject): ... coalforming process. Any comment on that? This is the first I have heard of highly-advanced prehistoric civilizations destroyed by nukes.[/nq]
0
[nq:2]Adrian: The tar sand oil, too heavy to be pumped, ... My versions aren't perfect: the first one has two clashing[/nq]
[nq:1]uses[/nq]
[nq:2]of "with", and the second sacrifices at least three ideas. (...)[/nq]
[nq:1]Then how about: "The tar sand oil, too heavy to be pumped, is strip-mined with the sand; the oil is then separated from the sand by using hot water, steam and

Related Questions