0
Deepcosmos Posted 5 years ago
Grammar

Seemingly "wanting"

Hello, everyone,

Recently I was with a client who had spent almost five hours with me. As we were parting for the evening, we reflected on what we had covered that day. Even though our conversation was very collegial, I noticed that my client was holding one leg at a right angle to his body, seemingly wanting to take off on its own. At that point I said, “You really do have to leave now, don’t you?” “Yes,” he admitted. “I am so sorry. I didn’t want to be rude but I have to call London and I only have five minutes!” Here was a case where my client’s language and most of his body revealed nothing but positive feelings. His feet, however, were the most honest communicators, and they clearly told me that as much as he wanted to stay, duty was calling.

My question is in the underlined part of above paragraph and I analyze it's structure in either way of followings;

1. it can be paraphrased, " ~ his body, which appeared to want to take off on its own". (the antecedent of which; "one leg at a right angle to his body")

2. underlined part is an adverbial clause which modifying 'one leg at a right angle to his body'.

Will appreciate if you advise which is more natural in your view.

Best RGDS,

  

Top answer

deepcosmos analyze it's structure its deepcosmos 1. it can be paraphrased, " ~ his body, which appeared to want to take off on its own". (the antecedent of which; "one leg at a right angle to his body") No.

  • deepcosmos analyze it's structure its deepcosmos 1.
  • it can be paraphrased, " ~ his body, which appeared to want to take off on its own".
  • (the antecedent of which; "one leg at a right angle to his body") No.
  • "Body" is so deeply buried in the grammar that it is not a candidate for the antecedent of "which".
  • deepcosmos 2.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
deepcosmosanalyze it's structure

its

deepcosmos1. it can be paraphrased, " ~ his body, which appeared to want to take off on its own". (the antecedent of which; "one leg at a right angle to his body")

No. "Body" is so deeply buried in the grammar that it is not a candidate for the antecedent of "which".

0
deepcosmosseemingly wanting to take off on its own.

It's an adjectival participle clause (also called a reduced relative clause). The antecedent is "leg". The participle is "wanting".

The corresponding relative clause goes like this:

(leg) which seemed to want to take off on its own

CJ

Related Questions