0
Norwolf Posted 7 years ago
Grammar

Secondary tenses

Hi, teachers. Here come three sentences:

1?Every time I see them, they're drinking.

2?Every time I see them, they've drunk.

3?Every time I see them, they've been drinking.

I wonder what the differences between the above are.

Thank you very much.

  

Top answer

Every time I see them, they're drinking. They are drinking at the time that you see them (or very near that time; they don't have to be literally swallowing the drink as you watch, but could have half-drunk glasses in front of them, say). Every time I see them, they've drunk.

  • Every time I see them, they're drinking.
  • They are drinking at the time that you see them (or very near that time; they don't have to be literally swallowing the drink as you watch, but could have half-drunk glasses in front of them, say).
  • Every time I see them, they've drunk.
  • Not natural.
  • e.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
norwolf1?Every time I see them, they're drinking.

They are drinking at the time that you see them (or very near that time; they don't have to be literally swallowing the drink as you watch, but could have half-drunk glasses in front of them, say).

norwolf2?Every time I see them, they've drunk.

Not natural. You can

0

1?Every time I see them, they're drinking. The continuous tense indicates that the drinking occurs before I see hem, when I see them, and after I see them.

2?Every time I see them, they've drunk. This is correct grammar, but it is not natural English. We prefer to use the continuous tense. Note that 'drunk' is also an adjective, meaning ''intoxica

Related Questions