0
Anonymous Posted 11 years ago
Grammar

Second conditional - tense sequence

Hello everyone,

Please consider the following statement (two people talking in the present about the situation right now):

If I knew you how much you love him, I wouldn't criticize him so much.

The sequence of tenses rule suggests that it should be "loved" (If I knew how much you loved him…)

But if she still loves the man, is the original sentence (with the use of "love") grammatically correct?

Thank you.
  

Top answer

Correct usage: only single 'you' is enough. If i knew how much you love him, i wouldn't criticize him so much.

  • Correct usage: only single 'you' is enough.
  • If i knew how much you love him, i wouldn't criticize him so much.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

20 Answers
0
Correct usage: only single 'you' is enough.

If i knew how much you love him, i wouldn't criticize him so much.
0
I think instead of 'wouldn't' use of 'would never' will be much better.
0
Thank you (I am the original author of the post).

So either "loved" or "love" is optional in this particular case?
0
'Loved' would mean that she might or might not be in love with him at present. But you clearly mean that she is in love with him at present so only 'Love' is correct.
0
AnonymousThe sequence of tenses rule suggests that it should be "loved" (If I knew how much you loved him…)
The more idiomatic sentence has the past tense "loved."
The present tense is not wrong, but not what a native speaker would naturally say.
0
Anupam verma'Loved' would mean that she might or might not be in love with him at present. But you clearly mean that she is in love with him at present so only 'Love' is correct.
That is not correct. Please see AS's answer.
0
AnonymousIf I knew you how much you love him, I wouldn't criticize him so much.
Actually, this is far more likely:

If I had known how much you loved him, I wouldn't have criticised him so much.
0
Fivejedjon,

No, I am afraid you are incorrect, given the context. You are using past perfect, so it's a situation that it's in the past. Here, two people are talking about the present. Say, a mother-in-law who constantly and continuously criticizes her son-in-law. So she tells her daughter that if she knew he much the daughter loved him, she'd be less critical.

It looks like the
0
AnonymousFivejedjon,No, I am afraid you are incorrect, given the context. You are using past perfect, so it's a situation that it's in the past. Here, two people are talking about the present. Say, a mother-in-law who constantly and continuously criticizes her son-in-law. So she tells her daughter that if she knew he much the daughter loved him, she'd be less critical.It

Related Questions