0
Ivanhr Posted 15 years ago
Grammar

Same

My grammar book says that "same" is normally preceded by "the". However , I've encountered many sentences where it's preceded by "a".

Ex

When a same sentence includes a background event and another event that interrupts it, the imparfait is used for the continuous event while the passé composé is used for the sudden one. (eg: Je lisais mon livre quand il est arrivé.)

As far as I can see, "same" can be safely left out and the sentence would still have the same meaning.

Any thoughts?
  

Top answer

Ivanhr My grammar book says that "same" is normally preceded by "the". This is correct. However , I've encountered many sentences where it's preceded by "a".

  • Ivanhr My grammar book says that "same" is normally preceded by "the".
  • This is correct.
  • However , I've encountered many sentences where it's preceded by "a".
  • That's surprising; it's very unusual.
  • Ex When a same sentence includes a background event and another event that interrupts it, the imparfait is used for the continuous event while the passé composé is used for the sudden one.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

3 Answers
0
IvanhrMy grammar book says that "same" is normally preceded by "the". This is correct.

However , I've encountered many sentences where it's preceded by "a". That's surprising; it's very unusual.

Ex
When a same sentence includes a background event and another event that interrupts
0
Thanks, Rover. So, do you think it's ok to use it that way? I certainly don't see anything wrong with it semantically.
0
Yes. Omit same in the last sentence.

Rover

Related Questions