0
Anonymous Posted 10 years ago
Grammar

right use of sentense

if I were/ had I been a bird.. which one is correct?
  

Top answer

) If I had been a bird (This does not make sense. You are now a live human being. ) If I had been born a bird (OK)

  • ) If I had been a bird (This does not make sense.
  • You are now a live human being.
  • ) If I had been born a bird (OK)
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

3 Answers
0
if I were a bird (OK.)

If I had been a bird (This does not make sense. You are now a live human being. We cannot transmute ourselves into a different animal species.)

If I had been born a bird (OK)
0
if I were a bird (now) (formal)
if I was a bird (now) (informal)
if I had been a bird (at some time in the past)

(Cross-posted.)
0
AlpheccaStarsIf I had been a bird (This does not make sense. You are now a live human being. We cannot transmute ourselves into a different animal species.)
I don't really agree with this I'm afraid. "If I had been a bird, I could have flown across the ocean" ... well, obviously it is impossible that one could actually be a bird either now or at any time in th

Related Questions