0
Snuppelina Posted 12 years ago
Grammar

respectively - where to place it

Hi, would it be correct to place the word 'respectively' in here:

The cross-sections turned out to be 2 and 3 times lower, respectively, than those of X in the Y reaction.

Thanks
  

Top answer

There is no way of judging whether the word is even correct in the sentence without seeing the inclusion of the 2 cross-section expressions.

  • There is no way of judging whether the word is even correct in the sentence without seeing the inclusion of the 2 cross-section expressions.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

9 Answers
0
There is no way of judging whether the word is even correct in the sentence without seeing the inclusion of the 2 cross-section expressions.
0
The whole sentence is:
The cross-sections of the reactions X and Y turned out to be 2 and 3 times lower, respectively, than those of X element in the Y reaction.
0
snuppelinaThe whole sentence is:The cross-sections of the reactions X and Y turned out to be 2 and 3 times lower, respectively, than those of X element in the Y reaction.
Can a "cross-section" be "lower"?
0
Small would be better, I think
0
snuppelinaThe cross-sections of the reactions X and Y turned out to be 2 and 3 times lower, respectively, than those of X element in the Y reaction.
Frankly, I don't see how a cross-section of anything can be either 'lower' or 'smaller', but as far as the structure is concerned, there is no need for the commas:

The cross-sections of the reactions X
0
Thank you very much!
I thought 'respectively' always requires a comma. Would a comma be a mistake? Or is it simply a difference between American and British English?
0
Ah, I think I can feel the difference!
0
snuppelinaSmall would be better, I think
If a cross-section is said to be "smaller", I would understand that to mean "smaller in area". I don't know whether that makes sense in your case; I'm not sure in what sense you are using the term "cross-section".
0
snuppelinaI thought 'respectively' always requires a comma. Would a comma be a mistake? Or is it simply a difference between American and British English?
The commas with short adverbials are gradually being done away with; you will probably meet proponents of both viewpoints.

Related Questions