0
JaxTeller Posted 12 years ago
Grammar
Reported speech in Minutes
I have to take minutes of a meeting, but I am quite confused at the moment. Here are some sentences which got me confused:
''Mr Johnson: Latin America and Asia produce the same products, so I suggest to close the factories in Latin America''
Since everything has to be in reported speech, I wrote this: ''Mr. Johson said that Latina America and Asia produce the same products. He suggested to close the factories in America''.
I have my doubts about my reported speech version. Since most of the time Simple Present become simple past in reported speech, should the word ''produce'' be changed in ''produced''?, if so, won't this change the meaning of the sentence. Won't it mean that they produced the same products in the past, but nowadays they don't. My teacher said that everything has to be in reported speech, but since this kind of changes the meaning of the sentence, I got confused.
Here is another sentence which got me confused:
Mr Johnson: I do not want to downsize because my companies are profitable.
what is the reported speech of this when taking minutes?
Please help me out, the assignment is due tomorrow morning.
''Mr Johnson: Latin America and Asia produce the same products, so I suggest to close the factories in Latin America''
Since everything has to be in reported speech, I wrote this: ''Mr. Johson said that Latina America and Asia produce the same products. He suggested to close the factories in America''.
I have my doubts about my reported speech version. Since most of the time Simple Present become simple past in reported speech, should the word ''produce'' be changed in ''produced''?, if so, won't this change the meaning of the sentence. Won't it mean that they produced the same products in the past, but nowadays they don't. My teacher said that everything has to be in reported speech, but since this kind of changes the meaning of the sentence, I got confused.
Here is another sentence which got me confused:
Mr Johnson: I do not want to downsize because my companies are profitable.
what is the reported speech of this when taking minutes?
Please help me out, the assignment is due tomorrow morning.
Top answer
Emre25 reported speech of this when taking minutes? Your teacher may insist on backshifting to the past tense for all reported speech. In my opinion, however, minutes can be reported in the present tense.
- Emre25 reported speech of this when taking minutes?
- Your teacher may insist on backshifting to the past tense for all reported speech.
- In my opinion, however, minutes can be reported in the present tense.
- Mr.
- Johnson said that Latin America and Asia produce/produced the same products.
Get the Weekly English Kit 📬
New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.
4 Answers
0
Emre25reported speech of this when taking minutes?Your teacher may insist on backshifting to the past tense for all reported speech. In my opinion, however, minutes can be reported in the present tense.
Mr. Johnson said that Latin America and Asia produce/produced the same products. He suggested closing the factories in Ameri
00
So it won't change the actual meaning of the sentence if I were to use produced instead of produce? or were profitable vs profitable?
Thanks
Thanks
00
Emre25So it won't change the actual meaning of the sentence if I were to use produced instead of produce? or were profitable vs profitable?ThanksNo. Whenever a native speaker hears (or reads) reported speech, he automatically adjusts the statement to the proper time period.
Because of this, you can always use backshifting. It's always correct.
00
Related Questions