0
HSS Posted 19 years ago
Grammar

Remember + -ing, Remember + Having + Past Participle

0Hi, how are you? Good I hope!02br
02br
00Do you feel any nuance between the two?02br
02br
00[1] He remembers being bitten by a dog.02br
02br
00[2] He remembers having been bitten by a dog.02br
02br
00Best,02br
02br
00Hiro0-
  

Top answer

0 Very little difference. The second seems stiffer, more formal. It contains more words than necessary.

  • 0 Very little difference.
  • The second seems stiffer, more formal.
  • It contains more words than necessary.
  • It also makes the memory more removed from the person remembering.
  • In the first sentence the person recalls the event itself; in the second, strictly speaking, only the fact that the event occurred.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

4 Answers
0
0 Very little difference. The second seems stiffer, more formal. It contains more words than necessary. It also makes the memory more removed from the person remembering. In the first sentence the person recalls the event itself; in the second, strictly speaking, only the fact that the event occurred. In the first sentence the person's memory seems a little more vivid.02br
02
0
0You may wish to add some ‘adjunct’ to each of your sentences to clarify the use of the passive indefinite and the passive perfect: 02br
02br
00[1] He remembers being bitten by a dog (2 years ago in that country trip).02br
02br
00[2] He remembers having been bitten by a dog (since he was young).02br
02br
00As the word implies, adjuncts
0
0 01blockquote
01cite10CalifJim12cite10Very little difference. The second seems stiffer, more formal. It contains more words than necessary. It also makes the memory more removed from the person remembering. In the first sentence the person recalls the event itself; in the second, strictly speaking, only the fact that the event occurred. In the fi
0
0 Yes, you could say that. You could also say "I couldn't ... as I was supposed to meet".02br
02br
00 By the way, this is really a second question. Next time please make a separate post for each question. It makes it much easier for all the forum members to find topics of interest to them. Thanks!02br
02br
00 CJ0-

Related Questions