0
Sweetest Posted 17 years ago
Grammar
Relative Clause
Hello, there are two questions as below
1. They are the ones who ____ tried on the costumes yet.
2. I am the one who ____ tried on the costume yet.
My answer for the two questions are the same --- haven't
But one of my teaching partner (from USA), he told me the answer for 2nd question is "hasn't", with no doubt.
I ask him about the reason, then he just told me that English is his mother language, he knows it well.
He was so sure the no one would use "haven't" in the 2nd question.
I'm really confused, the answer "hasn't" is against the grammar I learned before,
and he was so sure that using "haven't" is totally wrong.
If the answer got to be "hasn't",
my explanation is "who hasn't tried on the costume yet" describe "the one", not " I " in 2nd question.
Am I right? and why can't I use "haven't" in the 2nd question?
Thank you all in advance.
1. They are the ones who ____ tried on the costumes yet.
2. I am the one who ____ tried on the costume yet.
My answer for the two questions are the same --- haven't
But one of my teaching partner (from USA), he told me the answer for 2nd question is "hasn't", with no doubt.
I ask him about the reason, then he just told me that English is his mother language, he knows it well.
He was so sure the no one would use "haven't" in the 2nd question.
I'm really confused, the answer "hasn't" is against the grammar I learned before,
and he was so sure that using "haven't" is totally wrong.
If the answer got to be "hasn't",
my explanation is "who hasn't tried on the costume yet" describe "the one", not " I " in 2nd question.
Am I right? and why can't I use "haven't" in the 2nd question?
Thank you all in advance.
Top answer
Hi, Welcome to the Forum. there are two questions as below 1. They are the ones who __ tried on the costumes yet.
- Hi, Welcome to the Forum.
- there are two questions as below 1.
- They are the ones who __ tried on the costumes yet.
- 2.
- I am the one who __ tried on the costume yet.
Get the Weekly English Kit 📬
New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.
5 Answers
0
Hi,
Welcome to the Forum.
there are two questions as below
1. They are the ones who __ tried on the costumes yet.
2. I am the one who __ tried on the costume yet.
My answer for the two questions are the same --- haven't
But one of my teaching partner (from USA), he told me the answer for
Welcome to the Forum.
there are two questions as below
1. They are the ones who __ tried on the costumes yet.
2. I am the one who __ tried on the costume yet.
My answer for the two questions are the same --- haven't
But one of my teaching partner (from USA), he told me the answer for
00
0
Ah...you just registered.
I was just about to post this question for you.
Enjoy your time here.
This website is helpful.
You can come straight here whenever you are confused.
I was just about to post this question for you.
Enjoy your time here.
This website is helpful.
You can come straight here whenever you are confused.
00
0
You did not recognize me?
I think my account wording is very obvious.
I am the one who asked for your son's picture on a
I think my account wording is very obvious.
I am the one who asked for your son's picture on a
0
Related Questions