0
Catttt Posted 6 years ago
Grammar

Reference of "saying"

Does the highlighted "saying" in the following text refer to "Freud" or "the child"?


Text:

Even Freud points to the double-edged nature of this scenario. In an intriguing footnote in ‘Beyond the Pleasure Principle’, he describes the child greeting the mother’s return with the words ‘bebi o-o-o-o!’, saying that in his solitude the child has ‘found a method of making himself disappear. He has discovered his reflection in a full-length mirror which did not quite reach the ground, so that by crouching down he could make his mirror image
“gone”.’

  

Top answer

in terms of grammar it's a bit unclear. But in terms of meaning, I'd say it clearly refers to Freud. The concept introduced by 'saying .

  • in terms of grammar it's a bit unclear.
  • But in terms of meaning, I'd say it clearly refers to Freud.
  • The concept introduced by 'saying .
  • .
  • ' is not one that such a young child could come up with.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0

in terms of grammar it's a bit unclear.

But in terms of meaning, I'd say it clearly refers to Freud. The concept introduced by 'saying . . . ' is not one that such a young child could come up with.

Clive

Related Questions