0
Tanit Posted 19 years ago
Grammar

"is recommended": pattern?

I know that possible patterns for recommend are:

The teacher recommended (that) we should read that book.
The teacher recommended that we read that book.
The teacher recommended reading that book.


but not:

*The teacher recommended to read that book.

What about the passive form? Is to be recommended + infinitive possible? Today I came across the following sentence in an academic paper written by a British scholar:

"The reader is recommended to read White (2000) in order to understand the evolution of the public perception methodology",

which sounded odd to me. Honestly, I don’t know what I would’ve written, though Emotion: smile … Maybe:
  • (a) It is recommended that the reader read (ugh!)
  • (b) The reader is recommended that he should read
However, I did a bit of search on the net in British websites only and I found a great deal of occurrences for “is recommended to”. Even leaving aside those where “is recommended to” is actually followed by a noun, there’s still an impressive number of hits for “is recommended to” + verb; moreover, many of them are in governmental websites. For instance,

The Committee is recommended to note membership of Functional Bodies and London Borough Councils and …
The Board is recommended to agree the revised timetable ...
The Lead Member is recommended to agree an interim charging policy based on …


I'd like to ask some questions:
  1. Is really this pattern ok in the passive?
  2. If yes, is it common/formal/legalese?
  3. How would native speakers use “recommend” in the passive?
  4. Would sentences (a) and (b) be possible?
Thank you in advance!
Emotion: smile
  

Top answer

Although you mark it "ugh", I would use a . Never b . ) CJ

  • Although you mark it "ugh", I would use a .
  • Never b .
  • ) CJ
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

4 Answers
0
Although you mark it "ugh", I would use a. Emotion: smile
Never b.

(Just my personal opinion.)

CJ
0
CalifJim (Just my personal opinion.)
Thanks, that's a highly appreciated opinion. Emotion: smile
I
0
Dear Tanit,

You couldn't see one of my posts here because I deleted it. What I wrote was already written by CJ.
0
DollYou couldn't see one of my posts here because I deleted it.

I see. Thanks, Doll.

Related Questions