0
Guest Posted 21 years ago
Grammar

"a" or "an"?

Is it "a" historical outline or "an" historical outline?
  

Top answer

AmE at least permits 'an' when followed by an unstressed though pronounced 'h' syllable. A/An historical document A/An Hawaiian guitar Somewhere previously I had a discussion with Mr Pedantic on this topic, and it may be viewed more strictly in BrE.

  • AmE at least permits 'an' when followed by an unstressed though pronounced 'h' syllable.
  • A/An historical document A/An Hawaiian guitar Somewhere previously I had a discussion with Mr Pedantic on this topic, and it may be viewed more strictly in BrE.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

12 Answers
0
AmE at least permits 'an' when followed by an unstressed though pronounced 'h' syllable.

A/An historical document
A/An Hawaiian guitar

Somewhere previously I had a discussion with Mr Pedantic on this topic, and it may be viewed more strictly in BrE.
0
Thank you very much for your help. Excuse my ignorance please, but I do'nt know what "AmE" or "BrE" means.
0
'American English' and 'British English'. (Sorry. Sometimes we forget we have newcomers.)
0
Thank you again for your answers. One more question: What would be an example of a "stressed" H (in which case "an" would not be appropriate)?
0
I was not precise the first time-- I mean a stressed/unstressed initial syllable beginning with /h/:

The /hi/ of 'historical' is unstressed, permitting 'an historical'.
The /'hi/ of 'history' is stressed, requiring 'a history'.
0
I truly appreciate your help. Thank you!
0
The word 'an' is used when the word proceeding begins with a vowel, otherwise 'a' is used.
0
Dear,

It was the first time I've heard about "an historical". I know that we must use a before words that begin with vowel sound. But in /hi 'stor i kal/, hi is not a vowel sound.

So, could you please explain this case in more detail?


P/S: I'm a newcomer, and I hope that I will have a better English, so, in my posts, when I make grammatical
0
It was the first time I've heard about "an historical". I know that we must use a before words that begin with vowel sound. But in /hi 'stor i kal/, hi is not a vowel sound.


JT: The sound is dropped in some dialects and even in some individuals speech when using this word, Averell. So while is not a vowel sound, is so we get,

an istorical meeting.

Related Questions