0
Usenet Posted 23 years ago
Usage

Question mark Question AGAIN

One more time. Would you place a question mark at the end of the following sentences:
1) How could the Liberals claim to be an anti-socialist party when theyhad let the reds into government, the Tories asked.
2) You know when I asked you if we are ok, I just wanted to know if I'mupsetting you at all.
Would I classify both of these as rhetorical?
Thanks,
James
  

Top answer

[nq:1]One more time. Would you place a question mark at the end of the following sentences: 1) How could the ... ok, I just wanted to know if I'm upsetting you at all.

  • [nq:1]One more time.
  • Would you place a question mark at the end of the following sentences: 1) How could the ...
  • ok, I just wanted to know if I'm upsetting you at all.
  • "
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

5 Answers
0
[nq:1]One more time. Would you place a question mark at the end of the following sentences: 1) How could the ... ok, I just wanted to know if I'm upsetting you at all. Would I classify both of these as rhetorical?[/nq]
Not sure about the question you're asking but it does strike mne that the second sentence ought to read:
"You know when I asked you if we were ok, I just wanted to know if I
0
[nq:1]One more time. Would you place a question mark at the end of the following sentences: 1) How could the ... ok, I just wanted to know if I'm upsetting you at all. Would I classify both of these as rhetorical?[/nq]
No. I would classify them both as "indirect questions," because they quote or refer to direct questions. No question marks needed.

Now, this alone:
"How could the L
0
[nq:1]One more time. Would you place a question mark at the end of the following sentences: 1) How could the Liberals claim to be an anti-socialist party when they had let the reds into government, the Tories asked.[/nq]
No.**
[nq:1]2) You know when I asked you if we are ok, I just wanted to know if I'm upsetting you at all.[/nq]
No.**
**Nor anywhere else in the sentence.
[nq:1
0
[nq:1]One more time. Would you place a question mark at the end of the following sentences: 1) How could the Liberals claim to be an anti-socialist party when they had let the reds into government, the Tories asked.[/nq]
I'd write this as
"How could the Liberals... let the reds into government?" the Tories asked.
But I'd probably write it as
The Tories asked how the Liberals could
0
[nq:2]One more time. Would you place a question mark at ... at all. Would I classify both of these as rhetorical?[/nq]
[nq:1]Not sure about the question you're asking but it does strike mne that the second sentence ought to read: "You know when I asked you if we were ok, I just wanted to know if I was upsetting you at all."[/nq]
I'd correct "ok" to either "OK" or "okay", take your pick.

Related Questions