0
HanJH Posted 18 years ago
Grammar

Question about tense

Hello,

Which one do you think is proper?

A. Kim no longer buys the salad dressing and other condiments that she bought until last year.
B. Kim no longer buys the salad dressing and other condiments that she had bought until last year.

Thank you in advance.
  

Top answer

A. Kim no longer buys the salad dressing and other condiments that she bought until last year. B.

  • A.
  • Kim no longer buys the salad dressing and other condiments that she bought until last year.
  • B.
  • Kim no longer buys the salad dressing and other condiments that she had bought until last year.
  • Both are possible.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

3 Answers
0
A. Kim no longer buys the salad dressing and other condiments that she bought until last year.
B. Kim no longer buys the salad dressing and other condiments that she had bought until last year.
Both are possible. The first is a sort of abbreviation of the second. The simple past is often substituted for the past perfect when the meaning is obvious.
I would have said
0
Thank you, CJ.
This forum makes me happy.
0
i think the answer is using Had been bought?????? because the sentence refers to passsive voice...
i am sory if i am wrong

Related Questions