0
Usenet Posted 23 years ago
Usage

"Qualitative"

What is a "qualitative difference" between two things? Looking up "qualitative" just gets "having or pertaining to a quality," which is no help to me at all in context.

"Any sentence that begins 'Humans would never be so stupid as to...' is very probably wrong." -David M. Palmer, on Usenet
  

Top answer

[nq:1]What is a " qualitative difference" between two things? [/nq] If there's a qualitative difference between two things, it means they're different kinds of things. The opposite is a quantitative difference: the same kind of thing, but in different amounts.

  • [nq:1]What is a " qualitative difference" between two things?
  • [/nq] If there's a qualitative difference between two things, it means they're different kinds of things.
  • The opposite is a quantitative difference: the same kind of thing, but in different amounts.
  • Usually the main reason for referring to a qualitative difference is to emphasize that it's not just quantitative.
  • -Aaron J.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

42 Answers
0
[nq:1]What is a "qualitative difference" between two things? Looking up "qualitative" just gets "having or pertaining to a quality," which is no help to me at all in context.[/nq]
If there's a qualitative difference between two things, it means they're different kinds of things. The opposite is a quantitative difference: the same kind of thing, but in different amounts. Usually the main
0
[nq:1]What is a "qualitative difference" between two things? Looking up "qualitative" just gets "having or pertaining to a quality," which is no help to me at all in context.[/nq]
It's a difference which, while real, is not directly measurable that is, in order to measure it, a surrogate "quantitative" difference would need to be used.

Cheers, Harvey
Ottawa/Toronto/Edmonton
0
[nq:1]What is a "qualitative difference" between two things? Looking up "qualitative" just gets "having or pertaining to a quality," which is no help to me at all in context.[/nq]
A qualitative difference is a difference that has not been measured properly. This is to be contrasted with a quantitative difference, which is supported by a measurement or a count..
"John is taller than
0
[nq:2]What is a "qualitative difference" between two things? Looking up ... which is no help to me at all in context.[/nq]
[nq:1]A qualitative difference is a difference that has not been measured properly. This is to be contrasted with a quantitative difference, which is supported by a measurement or a count..[/nq]
Quibble mode: Shouldn't that be "has not been measured precisely" r
0
[nq:2]A qualitative difference is a difference that has not been ... difference, which is supported by a measurement or a count..[/nq]
[nq:1]Quibble mode: Shouldn't that be "has not been measured precisely" rather than "properly"? In situations where it's appropriate to leave precision out of the equation, the "propriety" of a lack of measurement isn't really a factor.[/nq]
I understand th
0
snip
[nq:1]I understand the quibble, but I'm not sure that your formulation deals properly or precisely with it. It might be ... suggests that worthwhile methods might not have been employed, and a qualitative difference is often not amenable to meaningful measurement.[/nq]
Maybe the problem is that we're trying to define a qualitative difference in terms of what it's not, rathe
0
[nq:1]Quibble mode: Shouldn't that be "has not been measured precisely" rather than "properly"? In situations where it's appropriate to leave precision out of the equation, the "propriety" of a lack of measurement isn't really a factor.[/nq]
By "properly", I mean that the measurement must be of sufficient precision to establish the difference beyond all reasonable doubt. Thus, I might say:- "T
0
[nq:1]I understand the quibble, but I'm not sure that your formulation deals properly or precisely with it. It might be ... suggests that worthwhile methods might not have been employed, and a qualitative difference is often not amenable to meaningful measurement.[/nq]
The discussion of measurement at all is an error. Height and width are qualitatively different. They can each be measured, and
0
[nq:2]What is a "qualitative difference" between two things? Looking up ... which is no help to me at all in context.[/nq]
[nq:1]It's a difference which, while real, is not directly measurable that is, in order to measure it, a surrogate "quantitative" difference would need to be used.[/nq]
This seems unlikely. . . . Classical and mediaeval philosophers spent quite a lot of time try
0
The inimitable "Don Phillipson" (Email Removed) stated one day
[nq:2]It's a difference which, while real, is not directly measurable ... it, a surrogate "quantitative" difference would need to be used.[/nq]
[nq:1]This seems unlikely. . . . Classical and mediaeval philosophers spent quite a lot of time trying to clarify the differences between quality and quantity. For example flavours (swe

Related Questions