0
Vsuresh Posted 9 years ago
Grammar

Pronoun....she/her

Please help me with this sentence.


A person as young as she /her should not be given such a responsibility.


I think it is she because the sentence actually reads thus:

A person as young as she is should not be given such a responsibility.

  

Top answer

vsuresh A person as young as she is should not be given such a responsibility. vsuresh A person as young as her should not be given such a responsibility. Both are correct.

  • vsuresh A person as young as she is should not be given such a responsibility.
  • vsuresh A person as young as her should not be given such a responsibility.
  • Both are correct.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
vsureshA person as young as she is should not be given such a responsibility.
vsureshA person as young as her should not be given such a responsibility.

Both are correct.

0

Your logic makes sense. In cases such as this, I always think of the three grammatical cases in which her must be used:

1. object: I know her.

2. indirect object: I gave her some money.

3. with a preposition: I came with her.

None of the above is applicable in your sentence because as is an adverb in it. Strictly speaking, only sh

Related Questions