0
Rex Posted 19 years ago
Grammar

Prime Minister had had good 10 years

0Mr Blair's election agent and close friend John Burton said he expected Mr Blair to continue as Sedgefield's MP until the next general election, unless he was offered a major international job. 02br
00Former Cabinet minister and Blair ally Alan Milburn said thought the prime minister "slightly regretted pre-announcing his retirement" by saying he would not seek a fourth term. 02br
02br
00"I think he would have preferred to stay longer," added Mr Milburn but he said the prime minister had had "a good 10 years" and had "fundamentally changed the country for the better". 02br
00Mr Blair's official spokesman insists he will remain "focused" on being prime minister until Labour has chosen his successor - a process expected to last seven weeks. 02br
02br
00------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------02br
00Please look at the following sentence of the above.02br
00"I think he would have preferred to stay longer," added Mr Milburn but he said the prime minister had had "a good 10 years" and had "fundamentally changed the country for better.02br
00To write ' 00the prime minister had had a good 10 years' sounds odd to me.02br
00I think it should be '00the prime minister had a good 10 years.02br
00What do you think?02br
0-
  

Top answer

0Rex, you seem to object to the past perfect just about every time you see it. I'm not sure why. It's simply used to show an action that was in the past, prior to another (more recent) action in the past.

  • 0Rex, you seem to object to the past perfect just about every time you see it.
  • I'm not sure why.
  • It's simply used to show an action that was in the past, prior to another (more recent) action in the past.
  • 02br 02br 00He had a good then years.
  • Then he announced his resignation.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

3 Answers
0
0Rex, you seem to object to the past perfect just about every time you see it. I'm not sure why. It's simply used to show an action that was in the past, prior to another (more recent) action in the past. 02br
02br
00He had a good then years. Then he announced his resignation. Before he announced his resignation, he had had a good ten year. Truly, it's fine.0-
0
0 Original seems fine to me. Just listen to it and learn the patterns. 0-
0
0 I thank both of you for the replies.02br
00Grammar Geek wrote the following:02br
02br
00He had a good then years. Then he announced his resignation. Before he announced his resignation, he had had a good ten year. Truly, it's fine.02br
02br
01font00Now it is clear to me.02font02br
01font

Related Questions