0
Aramahosi Posted 14 years ago
Grammar

Present Perfect VS Simple Past

If the sentence Some fans have expressed their dissapointment with his new look, while others have shrugged it off is changed as Some fans expressed their dissapointment with his new look, while others shrugged it off, what kind of differences of nuance will be generated?

Thanks in advance.

Quote from http://www.allkpop.com/2012/06/are-you-digging-taeyangs-new-hairstyle-on-monster
  

Top answer

Hi, If the sentence Some fans have expressed their dissapointment with his new look, while others have shrugged it off is changed as Some fans expressed their dissapointment with his new look, while others shrugged it off , what kind of differences of nuance will be generated? The Present Perfect focuses on the present situation, indicating that what happened in the past is important now. In a sports context, the past event probably happened recently.

— Clive

  • Hi, If the sentence Some fans have expressed their dissapointment with his new look, while others have shrugged it off is changed as Some fans expressed their dissapointment with his new look, while others shrugged it off , what kind of differences of nuance will be generated?
  • The Present Perfect focuses on the present situation, indicating that what happened in the past is important now.
  • In a sports context, the past event probably happened recently.
  • The Simple Past just describes past events.
  • Maybe they happened a week ago.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
Hi,

If the sentence Some fans have expressed their dissapointment with his new look, while others have shrugged it off is changed as Some fans expressed their dissapointment with his new look, while others shrugged it off, what kind of differences of nuance will be generated?

The Present Perfect focuses on the present situation, indicat
0

Related Questions