0
Contiluo Posted 15 years ago
Essay & Composition Writing

Present perfect tense

Please check out the following sentences. Which is acceptable?

(1) At the wedding banquet, Peter was so excited because he saw many old friends who have not seen for a long time.

(2) At the wedding banquet, Peter was very excited because he met many old frinds who had not seen for a long time.

In #1, is the adverb "so" acceptable? If it is replaced by "very", will it be better?

In #1, is the verb "saw" natural? If it is replaced by "met", will it be better?

In the adjective clause "...who have not seen for a long time", shoud the auxiliary verb "have" be replaaced by "had"?
  

Top answer

I have underlined the problems: (1) At the wedding banquet, Peter was so excited because he saw many old friends who have not seen for a long time. (2) At the wedding banquet, Peter was very excited because he met many old friends who had not seen for a long time.

  • I have underlined the problems: (1) At the wedding banquet, Peter was so excited because he saw many old friends who have not seen for a long time.
  • (2) At the wedding banquet, Peter was very excited because he met many old friends who had not seen for a long time.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

3 Answers
0
I have underlined the problems:

(1) At the wedding banquet, Peter was so excited because he saw many old friends who have not seen for a long time.
(2) At the wedding banquet, Peter was very excited because he met many old friends who had not seen for a long time.
0
(1) At the wedding banquet, Peter was excited because he saw many old friends who he had not seen for a long time.

(2) At the wedding banquet, Peter was very excited because he met many old friends who he had not seen for a long time.
0
(1) At the wedding banquet, Peter was (very) excited because he saw many old friends who(m) he had not seen for a long time.
(2) At the wedding banquet, Peter was very excited because he met many old friends who(m) he had not seen for a long time.

Both OK now.

Related Questions