0
English 1b3 Posted 16 years ago
Grammar

Present Perfect Sentence

Why is the present perfect used here?


I am here now, and I have decided to partake.


Thanks
  

Top answer

Given the context, what else would you suggest?

  • Given the context, what else would you suggest?
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

19 Answers
0
Given the context, what else would you suggest?
0
Nothing else.

I was just wondering if the present perfect was used because of the present simple 'am', or because in some way the verb affects or relates to the present. If either, which is it? I think it is the latter--but i'm unsure how it relates to the present.
0
We don't know; there is no context. All of these are possible:

I am here now, and I have decided to partake.
I am here now, and I decided to partake.
I am here now, and I think I will decide to partake.
I am here now, and I could decide to partake.
Etc
0
So what does the present perfect in the sentence indicate then?
0
A recent decision, I presume.
0
OK, thanks.

I read that these are the following uses of the present perfect, so you assume the present perfect in the topic sentence is used to indicate it happened in the recent past, #4.

1. When the past affects the present

2. Experiences

3. States or activities that started in the past, which have continued up to now.

0
Yes, but I have no idea what #2 means-- it is impossibly vague.
0
Experiences

Your experiences make you the person you are now. We don't use dates and times to give information on what makes you this person.

"I've been to New Zealand." (I know something about New Zealand.)

Make sense now?
0
I broke every bone in my body. Isn't that an experience?
0
I see what you mean. I've read a couple of sites sugessting we use the present perfect for experiences, but I always felt it overlapped with another use these credible sites detailed, namely past actions that affect the present.

What are your thoughts?

Thanks

Related Questions