0
Yellowstarstruck Posted 11 years ago
Grammar

Present Perfect

Hi, is my understanding of the below questions correct? Thanks, Fulvio
1. Have you ever eaten duck?
2. Have you eaten duck?
1 and 2 same meaning. An experience.
3. Have you ever eaten the duck?
4. Have you eaten duck?
Person pointing to a duck on a menu at a restaurant. An experience.

5. Have you eaten the duck?
Situation. You prepared a duck at home 3 hours ago and came back home and someone at it all. In this case this is present perfect form referring to a past action that was done.
  

Top answer

yellowstarstruck 3. Have you ever eaten the duck? yellowstarstruck A person is pointing to a duck an item on a menu at a restaurant.

  • yellowstarstruck 3.
  • Have you ever eaten the duck?
  • yellowstarstruck A person is pointing to a duck an item on a menu at a restaurant.
  • An experience.
  • OK.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
yellowstarstruck3. Have you ever eaten the duck?
yellowstarstruckA person is pointing to a duck an item on a menu at a restaurant. An experience.
OK.
yellowstarstruck5. Have you eaten the duck? Situation. You prepared a duck at home 3 hours ago and came back home and s
0
yellowstarstruckis my understanding of the below questions correct?
Yes.
yellowstarstruckSituation. You prepared a duck at home 3 hours ago and came back home and someone ate it all. In this case this is present perfect form referring to a past action that was done.
You have a few c

Related Questions