0
Anonymous Posted 11 years ago
Grammar

Preposition?

Hi all,

Which option should I choose for the blank below?

Losing weight is not only about anticipating swimsuit season or squeezing into skinny jeans, but it also means fighting a serious illness ------ the obese.

a) against
b) for

Thank you.
  

Top answer

Neither works. This might work: ... but it also means fighting a serious illness: obesity.

  • Neither works.
  • This might work: ...
  • but it also means fighting a serious illness: obesity.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

9 Answers
0
Neither works. This might work:

... but it also means fighting a serious illness: obesity.
0
Then this one is a poor question with a poor distractor.

Thank you GPY.
0
AnonymousWhich option should I choose for the blank below?
You wouldn't fight against someone with a serious illness, would you? That alone should give you your answer.

The idea is 'what it means for someone', specifically, 'what it means for the obese' (i.e., obese people).

CJ
0
Sorry, "for" can be correct, but it is easy to misread "for the obese" as meaning "on behalf of the obese", as I initially did. For that reason I recommend this reordering.

Losing weight is not only about anticipating swimsuit season or squeezing into skinny jeans, but, for the obese, it also means fighting a serious illness.
0
Thanks CJ

Then "for" is the correct choice here. But, from a native point of view, is this question is good or poor? What do you think?
0
AnonymousThen "for" is the correct choice here.
Yes. If I had to pick one, I'd choose "for".
Anonymousfrom a native point of view, is this question is good or poor?
It's not great. Personally, I don't care for it. For one thing, as I remember it, most research says that in multiple choice questions there should be at leas
0
Thank you. Here is the original question:

Losing weight is not only ---- anticipating swimsuit season or squeezing into skinny jeans, but it also means fighting a serious illness ---- the obese.

A) by / against
B) in / within
C) about / for
D) beyond / upon
E) at / towards

Test makers quoted a sentence from scientific american and distorted it much. Here
0
Anonymousoriginal sentence
That, of course, is fine. But do you see how the word order in the original makes more sense, just as GPY has already suggested?
Anonymousdistorted it
Yes. I see that.

CJ
0
You're right, I see the word order is much more sence in original sentence. Thank you CalifJim and GPY again Emotion: smile

Related Questions