0
Anonymous Posted 11 years ago
Grammar

Possible?

After I had waited for Jack, I left. Correct?
  

Top answer

Anonymous After I had waited for Jack, I left. Correct? I would add a time period: After I had waited an hour for Jack, I left.

  • Anonymous After I had waited for Jack, I left.
  • Correct?
  • I would add a time period: After I had waited an hour for Jack, I left.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

7 Answers
0
AnonymousAfter I had waited for Jack, I left. Correct?
I would add a time period:

After I had waited an hour for Jack, I left.
0
What about this one,
After I had talkEd to Jack, I left.
do I still need to use time period or its ok?
0
It's OK.

The point is that you need a point in time that marks the end of the first action. A finished conversation satisfies that. Waiting can go on forever, as we know from the story of Godot, so we have to give an end time explicitly.
0
One more question, Mam. Can I also say,'After I had been waiting for an hour, I left'. Thank you.
0
So what is the difference in meaning between 'After I had waiter for an hour, I left' and 'After i had been waiting for an hour, I left'? Or they mean almost the same and interchangeable?
0
After I had waited for an hour, I left.
After I had been waiting for an hour, I left.

The first is more commonly used.

Related Questions