0
Vincent Teo Posted 17 years ago
Grammar

Played a guitar once

Can I say,

(a) She has played the guitar once.

(b) She played a guitar once.
  

Top answer

If once = one time, then your sentences are OK. If once = previously, then: (a) She played a/the guitar once.

  • If once = one time, then your sentences are OK.
  • If once = previously, then: (a) She played a/the guitar once.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

8 Answers
0
If once = one time, then your sentences are OK.

If once = previously, then:


(a) She played a/the guitar once.

0
Thanks, can I say,

(a) She practised guitar / practised the guitar once.

(b) She is playing the guitar once (a day).

(c) She is practising the guitar / guitar once.

(d) She practised her guitar lesson once (a day).
0
These are OK:

(a) She practised guitar / practised the guitar once.

(b) She is playing the guitar once (a day).

(d) She practised her guitar lesson once (a day).
0
How about (c) ? Thanks!!
0
Stop bothering me, Vincent. As many times before, if it is not there when I list what is OK, it is not OK.
0
I believe Vincent has asked the 'guitar' question before. It seems he likes to ask the same or similar questions repeatedly. He should keep a record of what he has asked.
0
Sorry, I will bear in mind!

How about:

She played the guitar once a time.
0
No, 'once a time' is not an English formation.

Related Questions