0
Anonymous Posted 6 years ago
Grammar

Phrase structure

Is the "of" prepositional phrase in the following setence an adverbial or ellipsis of a noun phrase acting as complement?

One of my earliest memories is of a total eclipse of the sun.


Thank you.

  

Top answer

One of my earliest memories is of a total eclipse of the sun . While it's tempting to say it's a noun phrase with "that" ellipted, as in "(that) of a total eclipse of the sun", I'm inclined to say that the underlined element is a preposition phrase functioning directly as complement of "is". Since "a total eclipse of the sun" has "one of my earliest memories" as predicand, we could say that it was predicative.

  • One of my earliest memories is of a total eclipse of the sun .
  • While it's tempting to say it's a noun phrase with "that" ellipted, as in "(that) of a total eclipse of the sun", I'm inclined to say that the underlined element is a preposition phrase functioning directly as complement of "is".
  • Since "a total eclipse of the sun" has "one of my earliest memories" as predicand, we could say that it was predicative.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0

One of my earliest memories is of a total eclipse of the sun.

While it's tempting to say it's a noun phrase with "that" ellipted, as in "(that) of a total eclipse of the sun", I'm inclined to say that the underlined element is a preposition phrase functioning directly as complement of "is".

Since "a total eclipse of the sun" has "one of my earliest memories" as predic

Related Questions