0
Slide blue 9 Posted 8 years ago
Grammar

Past Perfect usage in Literature

I am a little bit confused about the Past Perfect usage in the following fragment which is from George Eliot's Adam Bede. I don't understand why she uses Past Perfect and I wish someone would explain it to me. Thank you!


All hands worked on in silence for some minutes, until the church clock began to strike six. Before the first stroke had died away, Sandy Jim had loosed his plane and was reaching his jacket; Wiry Ben had left a screw half driven in, and thrown his screwdriver into his tool-basket; Mum Taft, who, true to his name, had kept silence throughout the previous conversation, had flung down his hammer as he was in the act of lifting it; and Seth, too, had straightened his back, and was putting out his hand towards his paper cap. Adam alone had gone on with his work as if nothing had happened. But observing the cessation of the tools, he looked up, and said, in a tone of indignation, “Look there, now! I can't abide to see men throw away their tools i' that way, the minute the clock begins to strike, as if they took no pleasure i' their work and was afraid o' doing a stroke too much.”

  

Top answer

She wants to stress that all this happened before the first stroke of the clock died away.

  • She wants to stress that all this happened before the first stroke of the clock died away.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

3 Answers
0

She wants to stress that all this happened before the first stroke of the clock died away.

0

What else could it be? This is narrative in the past tense, which is typical of a novel - a novel typically depicts events in the past. And so perfect tenses in the past would be past perfect - like perfect tenses in the present would be present perfect.


The key thing here is that every worker dumped his tools as soon as the clock started to strike six - quitting time - "Befor

0
slide blue 9observing the cessation of the tools, he looked up, and said, in a tone of indignation,

I'd say this is the reference point from which all those "had"s are measured.

Adam said it because the others had done those things.

CJ

Related Questions