0
Anonymous Posted 6 years ago
Grammar

Past perfect continuous tense

He had been doing homework since morning when his mother called yesterday.


Although it is a totally correct sentence with sound grammar, I am wondering if the context is abit of mismatch.

I dont think the native speakers would come out with such a sentence.


As there are clearer ways to express this

Eg

1. He had been doing his homework since morning. Hence he looked tired when his mother called.


2. When his mother called yesterday, he was doing his homework.


Any native speakers to share your view on this?

  

Top answer

Yesterday, h e had been doing homework since 7 am in the morning when his mother called. It just needs some rearranging and a more exact time reference.

  • Yesterday, h e had been doing homework since 7 am in the morning when his mother called.
  • It just needs some rearranging and a more exact time reference.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0

Yesterday, he had been doing homework since 7 am in the morning when his mother called.

It just needs some rearranging and a more exact time reference.

0
anonymousI dont think the native speakers would come out with such a sentence.

don't

come up

It is not wrong. My only problem with it is that "yesterday" comes as a surprise. I would expect us to already know you're talking about yesterday and could therefore make it "He had been doing homework since morning when his mother called."

Related Questions