0
MartinHorut Posted 18 years ago
Grammar

past perfect

0 Hello, I wonder how past perfect is used in longer narratives. Let me pull a case in point:02br
00"I went fishing this morning. Before I went fishing, I had gone to a shop..." And now, shall I use the past simple or the past perfect when continuing with ... "I bought / had bought a few apples there."02br
02br
00Many thanks. 0-
  

Top answer

02br 00Do this:02br 02br 01i 00I went fishing this morning. 02i 02br 02br 00No call for past perfect-- it is a simple past narrative in clear chronological order. 0-

  • 02br 00Do this:02br 02br 01i 00I went fishing this morning.
  • 02i 02br 02br 00No call for past perfect-- it is a simple past narrative in clear chronological order.
  • 0-
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

16 Answers
0
0 .02br
00Do this:02br
02br
01i00I went fishing this morning. Before I went fishing, I went to a shop.I bought a few apples there.02i02br
02br
00No call for past perfect-- it is a simple past narrative in clear chronological order. 0-
0
0Hi,02br
02br
01font00I wonder how past perfect is used in longer narratives. Let me pull a case in point: 02font02br
02br
01font02font02br
02br
01font00"I went fishing this morning. Before I went fishing, I had gone to a shop..." And now, sh
0
0Clive, please allow me to interrupt for a second.02br
02br
00Let's examine the momentary shift in time using past perfect. If I would like to add another point that happened while I was at the store, do I need to use past perfect again? 02br
02br
00"I went fishing this morning. I had gone to a shop where I bought a few apples. Oh...I almost forgot, I [ha
0
0Hi,02br
02br
00No, I wouldn't do that. You have already performed the shift.02br
02br
00Clive0-
0
0Sorry, I promise this is my last post.02br
00Won't that be confusing to the reader since you use past tense to describe both events; in the past's past and in the past. Reader won't know02br
00whether you're still describing events that happened at the store or you've returned to the original time point (before the time shift occurred).02br
02br
00I w
0
0Hi,02br
02br
01font00Won't that be confusing to the reader since you use past tense to describe both events; in the past's past and in the past. Reader won't know02br
00whether you're still describing events that happened at the store or you've returned to the original time point (before the time shift occurred). 02font
02br
0
0 01blockquote
01cite10New2grammar12cite10Won't that be confusing to the reader since you use past tense to describe both events12blockquote
10 If everyone was really careful to always use the grammatically correct tense then using the "wrong" one might be pretty confusing, but that's not the case. English is pretty relaxed when it
0
0Huevos, could you give a couple of examples to support your statement. 02br
00They'll help me understand better. Thanks in advance!0-
0
0 01blockquote
01cite10New2grammar12cite10Huevos, could you give a couple of examples to support your statement.12blockquote
10 Bob 01font00went02font00 home because his wife 01font00had fallen02font00 over in the shower and 01font
0
0English is pretty relaxed when it comes to past events and we often use the past indefinite where the past imperfect, past perfect, or present perfect might be grammatically preferable, but, because we are all used to hearing it we don't find it confusing02br
02br
00Are the first sentences what you said grammatically preferable?02br
02br
00If so, I think

Related Questions