0
Yellowstarstruck Posted 5 years ago
Grammar

Past or Present

Hi! Is the below sentence past or present tense? Thanks, Fulvio

1. Thank you Benny for being a wonderful comedian!

  

Top answer

It is not very useful to grammatically analyze old fixed expressions like "thank you", but you can think of it as short for "I thank you". You left out some mandatory commas. " Also, the exclamation point is lame.

  • It is not very useful to grammatically analyze old fixed expressions like "thank you", but you can think of it as short for "I thank you".
  • You left out some mandatory commas.
  • " Also, the exclamation point is lame.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

3 Answers
0

It is not very useful to grammatically analyze old fixed expressions like "thank you", but you can think of it as short for "I thank you".

You left out some mandatory commas. The addressee is set off with commas in direct address: "Thank you, Benny, for being a wonderful comedian!" Also, the exclamation point is lame.

0

It is neither. Being is a gerund. Some people would prefer it if Benny were set off with commas.

CB

0
yellowstarstruck

Hi! Is the below sentence past or present tense? Thanks, Fulvio

1. Thank you Benny for being a wonderful comedian!

In my opinion, from the grammar point of view, it is expressed in the present tense and the understood subject in that sentence is "I/We/They", depending on the context. The past tense form of the verb "thank" is "t

Related Questions