Past continuous vs past perfect continuous
Is "Benjamin was watching a movie before Alison came in." really wrong?
The app says had been watching / came is correct because the past continuous tense is wrong as it would not show that the first action started before the second. However I believe that "before" is enough to indicate that.
Top answer
Benjamin was watching a movie before Alison came in " This doe not tell us that he was still watching it. For that, say eg Benjamin was watching a movie when before Alison came in . Clive
- Benjamin was watching a movie before Alison came in " This doe not tell us that he was still watching it.
- For that, say eg Benjamin was watching a movie when before Alison came in .
- Clive
Get the Weekly English Kit 📬
New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.
Benjamin was watching a movie before Alison came in" This doe not tell us that he was still watching it.
For that, say eg Benjamin was watching a movie when before Alison came in.
Clive
0anonymousI believe that "before" is enough to indicate that.
Yes, but in any case 'had been watching' sounds a lot classier, and your app is probably aiming high.
It seems to me that combinations of a clause with the present continuous and a clause with the present simple usually have some kind of causal relationship, not just watching a movie and som
0
Related Questions