0
Tmn111 Posted 17 years ago
Grammar

Pass

Ten minutes hasn't passed yet.

Is this correct?

Thanks.
  

Top answer

Strictly speaking, I suppose it should be "Ten minutes haven't passed yet", but I'm fairly relaxed about using "hasn't" in everyday English. That quibble aside, it's a valid sentence -- but more information about the context is necessary to tell if it's "correct" in the situation you are intending to use it.

  • Strictly speaking, I suppose it should be "Ten minutes haven't passed yet", but I'm fairly relaxed about using "hasn't" in everyday English.
  • That quibble aside, it's a valid sentence -- but more information about the context is necessary to tell if it's "correct" in the situation you are intending to use it.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

7 Answers
0
Strictly speaking, I suppose it should be "Ten minutes haven't passed yet", but I'm fairly relaxed about using "hasn't" in everyday English.

That quibble aside, it's a valid sentence -- but more information about the context is necessary to tell if it's "correct" in the situation you are intending to use it.
0
It's actually quite common to use the singular verb with a block of time (as it is with a sum of money or a distance).

Ten minutes isn't a long time. Three miles is too far to walk in this heat. One hundred dollars was a fair bargain.

It's hard to say if it's right in your situation.
0
Thanks, I made a mistake.
I meant if "10 minutes haven't passed yet" is correct.
Thanks Emotion: smile
0
Maybe some examples would be useful. Barb, MrWordy, would you be able to think of a couple of examples where you might be more likely to use the singular or the plural?

I am thinking of a kid who has to wait for ten minutes before he can go to the bathroom, and wants to go anyway and the teacher says "No, be patient. Ten minutes hasn't/haven't passed yet".
I have always been undecid
0
My thinking was along those lines.

A: How much longer till we're there?
B: About ten minutes
<<four minutes later>>
A: Why aren't we theeeerrrreeee yeeeetttt? (whine)
B: Be patient! Ten minutes hasn't passed yet. Not even close. We'll be there soon.
0
Ah, I see. Yeah, in your example there doesn't seem to be any reason to use the plural... so the singular should be ok. So I guess in mine the singular is expected as well. Anyway, thanks.
0
KooyeenMaybe some examples would be useful. Barb, MrWordy, would you be able to think of a couple of examples where you might be more likely to use the singular or the plural?

In everyday English I would use "hasn't". In writing, if I was trying to be "correct" I might use "haven't" -- but looking at it again this is possibly being a bit pedantic; I think

Related Questions