0
Taka Posted 20 years ago
Grammar

over which

In the age of abundance, the apparent availability of virtually all material necessities tended to lead people to expect speedy gratification of their desires and to have little sense of the length of time over which people in other times and places had had to wait in order to have some of their more basic material needs satisfied.

About 'over which', if you were supposed to pin down the single word that the 'over which' refers to, which word would it be; 'the length (of time)' or 'time'?
  

Top answer

is both: the respective time interval

  • is both: the respective time interval
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

6 Answers
0
is both:
the respective time interval
0
So you don't think we can pin down a single word, right?
0
no,
a length of time
is a group of words with a meaning different from the components

but if you want to simplify things
it would be
time
which is more important
0
Marius Hancubut if you want to simplify things
it would be
time
which is more important

I don't think we can simplfy it that way, because 'people had to wait over time' wouldn't really make sense, would it?

But I don't think 'people had to wait over the length' would make sense either, so I asked the question.

It
0
I meant to simplify things for understanding, not to change the phrase
0
Right.

It's just, I didn't think it would be so easy for my students to understand it because they usually learn the mechanism of relative pronouns as something like this:

That is the house the house ten years ago=>That is the house in which/where I lived ten years ago

Related Questions