0
Teal lime Posted 7 years ago
Grammar

... or is she?

The following sentence is taken from a book:

Louise is stealing from my office... or is she?

My question is this:

Why is it "or is she?" and not "or isn't she?"

Thank you

  

Top answer

Those combinations are always framed as a statement followed by the affirmative question, not a negative. The question throws doubt on the truth of the claim just made. Such a question is equivalent to "Or maybe not".

  • Those combinations are always framed as a statement followed by the affirmative question, not a negative.
  • The question throws doubt on the truth of the claim just made.
  • Such a question is equivalent to "Or maybe not".
  • This plan is going to work — or is it?
  • Giacco will surely win the game — or will he?
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0

Those combinations are always framed as a statement followed by the affirmative question, not a negative. The question throws doubt on the truth of the claim just made. Such a question is equivalent to "Or maybe not".

This plan is going to work — or is it?
Giacco will surely win the game — or will he?
Our kids are always well behaved — or are they?

Th

Related Questions