0
Milky Posted 20 years ago
Grammar

Omitting "here" in AmEng.

I'm told that the "here" is necessary/cannot be omitted in AmEng in the following question:

Has the mailman been (here)?

Is that true?

----------------

In BrEng, one would normally hear:

Has the postman been?
  

Top answer

" does sound very odd to my American ears.

  • " does sound very odd to my American ears.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

7 Answers
0
You can say "Has the mailman come?"

But "Has the mailman been?" does sound very odd to my American ears.
0
What would be the most common expression in AmEng to ask if the mailman had delivered the mail?
0
Has the mailman come yet?
0
i don't understand what is the yet mean in you sentence, my definition of this (yet) mean is surprise , to emphasize the second event relate to the first event.
0
From www.m-w.com:

2 a (1) : up to now : so far <hasn't done much yet> -- often used to imply the negative of a following infinitive <have yet to win a game> (2) : at this or that time : so soon as now <not time to go yet>

Yet also means
0
Anonymousi don't understand what is the yet mean in you sentence, my definition of this (yet) mean is surprise , to emphasize the second event relate to the first event.
The word [yet] is one of those oddballs that learners have confusion with.

Consider the following sentence:

Paul borrowed my bike last week which he has not returned yet.

Related Questions