0
TeacherJapan Posted 4 years ago
Grammar

Of limited scope?

I get what the sentence is trying to say, but I am not sure about the structure of the underlined part. Could you help me figure it out?

Classify a whale as a mammal is to assert the generalization that all infants whales are provided with milk by their mothers, and this proposition is a general law, although of limited scope.

  

Top answer

teacherJapan Could you help me figure it out? I am surprised you haven't mentioned the other mistakes or corrected them. To classify a whale as a mammal is to assert the generalization that all infant whales are provided with milk by their mother s a nd that this proposition is a general law, although of limited scope.

  • teacherJapan Could you help me figure it out?
  • I am surprised you haven't mentioned the other mistakes or corrected them.
  • To classify a whale as a mammal is to assert the generalization that all infant whales are provided with milk by their mother s a nd that this proposition is a general law, although of limited scope.
  • I don't get what it is trying to say, "trying" being the operative word.
  • That sentence is faulty in several ways.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
teacherJapanCould you help me figure it out?

I am surprised you haven't mentioned the other mistakes or corrected them.

To classify a whale as a mammal is to assert the generalization that all infant whales are provided with milk by their mother

0
teacherJapanthis proposition is a general law, although of limited scope.

~ this proposition is a general law although it is a general law of limited scope.

That is, it's only about whales, i.e., it's limited to whales.

Or at least that's what I infer from that statement.

CJ

Related Questions