1) a valuable player
2) a of value player (??)
3) a player who is of value (??)
4) a player (who is) of value (??)
Sentences 2)~4) are grammatically correct?
One student asked me this question, but I couldn't answer this question clearly
I just said that 2) seemed to be incorrect, but 3) and 4) were possible
What do you think about this?
Hoony I just said that 2) seemed to be incorrect, but 3) and 4) were possible Yes. In fact 3) is not needed because 4) includes it (because of the parentheses). to be of [noun] ~ to be [adjective] See also CJ
New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.
HoonyI just said that 2) seemed to be incorrect, but 3) and 4) were possible
Yes. In fact 3) is not needed because 4) includes it (because of the parentheses).
to be of [noun] ~ to be [adjective]
See also
CJ
Hoony1) a valuable player
2) a of value player (??)
3) a player who is of value (??)
4) a player (who is) of value (??)
As appeared, the only correct and idiomatically correct is