0
Cho7712 Posted 13 years ago
Vocabulary

object raising

In comparison to these two sentences,
is there any chance for the second one to be grammatically correct?

1. This problem is hard to deal with.
2. To feel left behind is hard to deal with.
  

Top answer

It is perfectly correct grammar but may not occur very often, and thus may sound unnatural to native ears. An infinitive (to feel) can be used as the subject. CB

  • It is perfectly correct grammar but may not occur very often, and thus may sound unnatural to native ears.
  • An infinitive (to feel) can be used as the subject.
  • CB
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

8 Answers
0
It is perfectly correct grammar but may not occur very often, and thus may sound unnatural to native ears. An infinitive (to feel) can be used as the subject.

CB
0
Thank you for the answer.
But still I am not fully convinced of its correctness.
As clearly seen in 1, the operation applied to both 1,2 is object raising.
And sentence 1 is no doubt grammatical because the subject noun(this problem) is in fact the object of the preposition, whose original version is It is hard to deal with this problem.
Then, if we consider the original ver
0
cho7712Then, if we consider the original version of sentence 2, which is; It is hard to deal with to feel left behind.It is clearly ungrammatical. How can it be explained??
For me, the "original" version was the sentence you asked people to give their opinion about, and I did. Language isn't math. Many sentences can be changed in several ways and the resultan
0
Yes, I understand what you mean. I also agree with your point of view about language.
But I think the desire to know why it is so and to get an clear explanation about it is what all the learners eagerly want.
And as for me, some language matters,in themselves,are good motivation to learn English because I believe there must be complete solutions to those matters, which I just don't know w
0
cho7712Thank you for the answer.But still I am not fully convinced of its correctness.As clearly seen in 1, the operation applied to both 1,2 is object raising.And sentence 1 is no doubt grammatical because the subject noun(this problem) is in fact the object of the preposition, whose original version is It is hard to deal with this problem.Then, if we consider the origin
0
Thank you for the answer,
Then the sentence 'To feel left behind is hard to deal with' is correct only when the subject to-infinitive clause is extraposed in the original version. Is it right??
And I thought left behind means to be overshadowed by somebody else. Does this phrase mean something far different from what I've thought??
0
I'm sorry. I was unclear. I meant that I don't know what grammar principle is employed in placing the phrase in apposition.

I would not say that to feel left behind is necessarily a result of being overshadowed by someone else, although it might well be. It is not a set figure of speech but a metaphorical expression that evokes that feeling you get when you are literally left behind, when
0
Thank you for the answer.
For now, I think that your explanation is in full accord with the rule of extraposition. So it works well unless I'm mistaken.
And I am well informed of the phrase(left behind) meaning due to your specific explanation. The literal meaning is more close to loneliness!

Related Questions