0
Believer Posted 18 years ago
Grammar

NOUN

0Hi,02br
02br
00It has been known to me that a gerund can function as a noun and should or likely to be treated more as an uncountable noun than a countable noun.02br
02br
01i00Mixing of sugar and flour makes this dough02i00 ...02br
02br
00If you want to be specific, I think you could write:02br
02br
01i00The mixing of sugar and flour makes this dough ...02i02br
02br
00If you want to indicate the mixing being an instance of it or an example of it, you could write (I think) like this:02br
01i00 02i02br
02br
01i00A mixing of sugar and flour makes this dough ...02i02br
02br
00It could be more clear if you write this though (but the above example seems to be correct grammatically too):02br
02br
01i00An instance of sugar and flour makes this dough ... 02i02br
02br
00It has been to me that a quoted content (I may be wrong but what I call a quoted content is one that has quotation marks around it, whether or not they are done to quote someone's words or to highlight a word/words) can be treated an uncountble noun too.02br
02br
00"-ing" is not needed in your sentence. -- Just the mention of a case to highlight, I think.02br
02br
00The "-ing" is not needed in your sentence. -- Not just mentioning but specificallymentioning, I think.02br
02br
00A "-ing" is not needed in your sentence. -- An example of "-ing" use or an instance of "-ing" use, but this is what gives me trouble. I think whether a word in quotation marks can accommodate an indefinite article is predicated on whether its semantic meaning can embrace it. 02br
02br
00So, I think I would be able to say, depending on words, some words that are in quotation marks can accommodate its having an indefinite article, whereas some words that are in quotation marks can't accommodate the use because its semantic meaning and how it is used in sentences make it awkward at best if not wrong to have an indefinite article. Sounds plausible?02br
02br
00Sorry for a long post.0-
  

Top answer

0Do you mean something like this? 02br 01i 00An "I'm sorry" is not nearly enough. 02i 0-

  • 0Do you mean something like this?
  • 02br 01i 00An "I'm sorry" is not nearly enough.
  • 02i 0-
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

5 Answers
0
0Do you mean something like this? 02br
01i00An "I'm sorry" is not nearly enough. You're going to have to do a lot more than just apologize after what you've done!02i0-
0
0Hi Believer,02br
02br
00In terms of common usage, both your examples work with both definite and indefinite articles - i.e., countable and uncountable. I'd say your interpretation of the situation is correct.02br
02br
00In the case of quotes, we observe the "a/an" switch, based on the way the letter would be spel(t): an "ing"; an "s"; a "t"; a "w."0
0
0Yes, That sound like something I had in mind. The use of an indefinite article is what give me trouble sometimes. Thank you.0-
0
0Thank you, Avangi.02br
02br
00In my previous post, I should have used third-person verb tenses, 'sounds' and 'gives' -- proper subject-verb agreement wasn't made due to my carelessness.02br
02br
00Going back to your request for examples of cases where I would feel something in quotes could not be used with an indefinite article becauss of its semantic mea
0
0Hi Believer, I'm not brave enough or knowledgeable enough to give you a definitive answer. For starters, I'm not familiar with the implications of your expression, "a typical (known-to-be??) uncountable noun."02br
02br
00I think I can imagine situations where the semantic meaning of what's in quotes would have a bearing on it's "countable-ness," and others where it would n

Related Questions