0
Jackson6612 Posted 16 years ago
Grammar

Not logically necessary ; esp: empirical

1 contingent
2: not logically necessary ; esp: empirical
[M-W's Col. Dic.]

What is there which is logically required but empirically unnecessary, and vice versa? Please guide me.
  

Top answer

I'm not sure I follow, Jack. What is the main entry? - A.

  • I'm not sure I follow, Jack.
  • What is the main entry?
  • - A.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

12 Answers
0
I'm not sure I follow, Jack. What is the main entry?

- A.
0
As I recall, "logically" one distinguishes between a necessary condition and a sufficient condition. A rain storm is a sufficient condition for the street's being wet, but not a necessary one. That is, someone may have hosed it down.
So your formula is missing something. A is not necessary for B, from an emperical point of view.
(I think Jim is into this stuff. I'm real
0
Okay, not logically necessary but empirically true.

"Constant conjunction" seems to ring a bell. We know from experience (trial and error) that whenever we have A, B also shows up. We have no idea why. There's no logical reason why it should.
B is contingent on A, but B is not the "necessary" result of A in the logical sense.
Yo
0
Hi
AvangiA is not necessary for B, from an emperical point of view.
How would you differentiate between 'empirical point of view' and 'logical point of view'? I would say even from logical point of view B is not solely dependent upon A. Please guide me.
0
Sorry, Jack, I answered this at some length a day or two ago and somehow booted it. I didn't have the spirit to start over. I'll get back to it!
0
No problems.

Avangiand somehow booted it.
Does "booted" here mean to mess up, make an error,...? Please let me know.
0
Yes. That's accurate. "Fumbled" might be a synonym.

In this case I actually lost the whole thing. I was working from a note pad so I wouldn't lose it, and I did anyway!
0
AvangiI was working from a note pad so I wouldn't lose it, and I did anyway! Emotion: crying
Please don't b

Related Questions