0
Vcolts Posted 14 years ago
Grammar

negative toward, happy about - prepositional phrases or idioms?

Ex. Comments negative toward the candidate are being deleted without notice.

Are phrases like "negative toward & happy about" considered as prepositional phrases or just idioms?

Thanks in advance.
  

Top answer

Comments [that are] negative toward the candidate are being deleted without notice. The underlined is a reduced relative clause.

  • Comments [that are] negative toward the candidate are being deleted without notice.
  • The underlined is a reduced relative clause.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

7 Answers
0
Comments [that are] negative toward the candidate are being deleted without notice.

The underlined is a reduced relative clause.
0
If so, the rule about unable to directly reduce pronoun + verb only applies when the adjective cannot stand on its own?

The rule in application: Ex. "The man who is angry is outside" cannot be reduced to "the man angry is outside." Instead it has to be "the angry man is outside."

Thanks in advance.
0
Nevertheless, it has been done above.
0
Meaning we can reduce a relative clause even when there is an adjective? (both grammatically and academically safe as well?).
0
Various sites state that a relative clause cannot be directly reduced when there is an adjective:

"The man who is angry is outside" cannot be "the man angry is outside." Instead it should be "the angry man is outside."

However, we see sentences like the below:

People angry about the latest political scandal are protesting outside.
Comments negative toward the candi
0
You can here: Comments that are negative toward the candidate are being deleted without notice.

But you cannot here: The man who is angry is outside.

Related Questions